| Pastor |
Dates |
| The Rev. John Christian Frederick Heyer |
1837-1838 |
| The Rev. Emanuel Frey |
1838-1838 |
| The Rev. John McCron |
1839-1842 |
| The Rev. William H. Smith |
1843-1844 |
| The Rev. William Alfred Passavant |
1844-1855 |
| The Rev. Charles Porterfield Krauth |
1855-1859 |
| The Rev. Reuben Hill |
1860-1866 |
| The Rev. Samuel Laird |
1867-1879 |
| The Rev. Edmund Belfour |
1880-1892 |
| The Rev. David Harrison Geissinger |
1893-1907 |
| The Rev. George Justus Gongaware |
1907-1913 |
| The Rev. Thurston Orville Keister |
1913-1917 |
| The Rev. Charles Peter Raby McLaughlin |
1918-1925 |
| The Rev. Dr. Adam J. Holl |
1926-1947 |
| The Rev. Robert William Stackel |
1947-1955 |
| The Rev. Harold Raymond Albert |
1955-1965 |
| The Rev. John Thomas Braughler |
1966-1989 |
| The Rev. Dr. David Paul Gleason |
1989-2013 |
| The Rev. Brian Alan Evans |
2013- |